Monday, 18 June 2012

Life on Mars Analysis: Series 1, Episode 5


So more than a little overdue, here is my analysis for the fifth ep, which focuses on football. Now I don’t really give much of a shit about football, to be honest, but as far as storytelling goes, like many other subjects that bore me, a number of layers can be given. One is the obvious, the focus of the crime: hooliganism. However, as Sam points out, hooliganism shouldn’t be the only thing to focus on. Another thing is how people can bond over a simple pleasure in life just as much as they can ruin the enjoyment of it by taking things too far – in this case, watching a simple game. Once again, we’re given another contradiction of life: something that can make people happy can also make men fight and hate each other.

Among all of this, we also learn more about Sam. Naturally continuing a theme from the last episode, we specifically find out more about his early life with his parents: in the previous episode, it was his mum, in this, it’s his dad, despite the fact that we never see him in this ep. We just learn a lot about him, including that he wasn’t around much, which meant that the time they did spend together was really important to Sam, and that Sam doesn’t know where he is. I can’t tell you how much I love that that’s exactly the way Sam phrases it – no dodging the issue, no getting angsty about it when he’s asked, it’s just something he’s just had to live with for nearly his whole life. That lets us know a lot more about Sam in just one line that a lot of tv shows take an entire episode to flesh out. It gives us reason to wonder why he became a cop, and I mean really became a cop instead of letting a childhood dream die, that he might just have had a deeply personal reason to do it. Not that its stated in the episode, it’s really just a theory, but it’s one I genuinely believe the writers have given us, purely because, unlike so many other series I’ve watched where similar revelations are given but in a much more “dramatic” way, one that tries so hard to exploit so much drama out of it that it all eventually becomes sickening, in this series the writers assume we’re not idiots and just let us form our own theories based on one line. 

Have I mentioned how much I bloody love this show yet?

Another aspect I love is how football is used. As I've said before, I’m not the biggest fan of football, but football hooliganism is a great subject to tackle when done right, and…well, no surprises that the writers handled it completely right here. Because we see clearly that there’s nothing wrong with the game itself, in fact it’s something great that can bring people together. But like many great things, all it takes is a few stupid people to ruin it for everyone else. We see how this affects Sam more than anyone, as he knows what’s coming, and how much worse it’s going to get. It’s bad now, with a boy’s father ending up dead, but it’s gonna get so much worse, and a lot more innocent people are gonna end up dead by the hands of not gangs, but police, because of what's happening now. It’s interesting that there’s nothing directly personal to Sam in this story, like Sam stumbling across the body of a father of someone he knew as a kid or some bullshit like that, and yet it still affects him on multiple levels – as a policeman, as a fan of football, as someone who lost a father at far too young an age. Wonderfully complex and emotional writing of the character that avoids being exploitive. 

But it’s not all serious drama - it is Life on Mars, after all. One thing I have to mention is the excellent comedy writing given to us this ep by Sam and Gene working undercover in a pub, where Sam expects to easily talk to the customers but of course, even with his love of football, finds it difficult to blend in, while Hunt unsurprisingly blends in perfectly. Actually, thinking about it, there’s really nothing different about that: Sam has been, and will continue to be, the outsider in this world. The one who finds it difficult to talk to people, to blend in. Even (or should that be “especially”?) as the professional, undercover work in this world isn’t exactly his specialty. 

So, at the end of the day, we’re given an ep that uses football as a perfect way to explore how something that brings people together for the best reasons can also turn people against each other for the most stupid of reasons, both on society as a whole and, just as importantly, on our main character Sam. It’s a testament to Life on Mars really that it’s not one of my personal favourites and yet it’s still something I can find huge enjoyment in both watching and exploring its multiple layers.

No comments:

Post a Comment